Magic Eraser on Paint scuffs

Can You Use Magic Eraser on Painted Walls?

In Cleaning Products, Home Tips by Jamie

Are you trying to remove smudges off your painted walls? Have you tried many cleaning hacks but to no avail? Maybe it’s high time you try using a magic eraser. This innovative cleaning tool can practically clean “almost” everything! But, you might worry about discoloring your precious walls and ruining them with an uneven painted surface. Wondering if you can use a Magic Eraser on a painted wall? Learn what you need to know in our detailed Magic Eraser guide.

The magic eraser can keep most painted walls stain-free. However, it is not ideal for wood paneling, sealed, varnished, and finished surfaces that have been painted. The magic eraser can strip away the finish, leaving ugly scratches. Simply saying, you can use the magic eraser on a flat or matte wall but not on glossy painted ones. 

How can you use magic eraser on painted walls conveniently without peeling it off? Here are some things to consider before scrubbing some crayon marks off your wall.

Will a Magic Eraser Leave Marks on a Painted Wall?

It is possible to leave marks and discolor the painted walls with a magic eraser. Its residues can leave unsightly marks due to their abrasive property. But, it is avoidable if you use gentle strokes when cleaning and follow the strokes with a white absorbent towel.

Will a Magic Eraser Peel Paint off the Wall? Mr Clean Erase and Renew Magic Eraser, Original, 2 Count

A magic eraser can remove stains from almost all surfaces, no doubt. It is not designed to strip off dried and cured paints on the wall. Melamine foams are not strong enough to separate the paint particles as solvents do. When combined with water, the magic eraser will only cut through stains, grimes, and crayon marks on the wall.

However, it is a different thing when it comes to fresh and newly painted walls, wood paneling, and glossy wall finish. If you happen to splat paint on your wall, it can still be easily removed by the magic eraser. Once it has dried and cured, it may not come off unless you use an alcohol-based or solvent-based cleaner.

Does the Paint Type Matter?

The paint type that is compatible with the magic eraser does matter. High-shine and semi-gloss surfaces can be marred by their abrasives. Enameled, sealed, varnished, polished, and satin surfaces are also easily ruined by the magic sponge. It will cause a dull and uneven finish.

Melamine foams may also cause irreplaceable scratches in untreated wood and wood-stained furniture.

You can use the magic eraser just fine on non-glossy surfaces like flat paint and chalk paint. You may also use it in low-sheen paints like eggshell paints. Still, you need to exercise extra caution to avoid stripping it off with aggressive scrubbing.

Does the Paint Color Matter?

Does the Paint Color Matter

Can you use magic eraser on painted walls with darker colors, or is it better on lighter ones? Generally, magic erasers will have the best result when applied to light-colored surfaces, even on flat walls. That is because its abrasives may still leave dainty micro-scratch marks that can become obvious on darker walls.

You may still use a magic eraser on dark-colored paints though, provided you apply gentle force and follow it up with an absorbent towel. Also, wring the magic eraser well to remove the water before using it.

Can You Use a Magic Eraser on Primer?

A magic eraser is equivalent to 3000-grit sandpaper. If you want to remove stains on paint primer, this sponge is a handy tool for the job. It can easily agitate the stains and absorb them, however, it may not remove the primer once it has dried out.

Can You Remove Crayon Marks off Walls with a Magic Eraser? Mr. Clean Magic Eraser, Extra Durable, Shoe, Bathroom, and Shower Cleaner, Cleaning Pads with Durafoam, 10 Count

Yes, it is possible to remove crayon marks, pencils, and marker blots in a flat painted wall without damaging its surface. It is a go-to cleaning tool for removing many types of stains, dirt, and grimes that ordinary cleaning tools cannot handle. It does not contain any harsh chemicals, although it may leave a residue that can be remedied by wiping.

What’s the Recommended Way to Clean a Painted Wall?

The magic eraser may damage a painted wall, but it is dependent on the type of finish it has. So, determine the finish first before using a magic eraser. Here is how can you use magic eraser on painted walls (when applicable) without damaging them:

1. Prep the wall by wiping it to remove small dirt and particles that can further scratch the wall.

2. Wet the magic eraser and wring out excess water.

3. Perform a small patch test in an unnoticeable portion of the wall.

4. If the wall has no reaction and discoloration, proceed to scrub the stain or mark in a gentle circular motion. Apply firm but gentle pressure to avoid scraping a part of the paint off and give it an uneven and dull look.

5. Blot off the area with a clean, absorbent towel to remove residues after scrubbing.

Final Thoughts

Painted walls that are stained and marked can still be remedied using the magic eraser. This melamine foam is an effective tool for removing dirt and scuff marks without risking damage to some wall types. They work well on flat-painted walls but are not compatible with glossy and high-sheen ones. It may not damage dried-up and cured paints, but the magic eraser is still capable of removing fresh paints from walls.

Technically, it is safe to use on flat-painted walls since it cannot dissolve its particles. It will only cut through the impurities to revive and restore its appearance to its pristine look.

About the Author

Jamie

Jamie is the Founder of My Home Dwelling. He is a homeowner and enjoys sharing his homeowner tips with others. He has real estate experience working as a new home construction Realtor. Jamie has worked on numerous residential construction sites helping with interior and exterior renovations. He loves refinishing furniture, DIY home projects, and sharing his knowledge online.