The debate of a melamine sponge vs. magic eraser is real. Of course, you can depend on both to remove difficult, unwanted marks from many surfaces without leaving damage. Still, the difference lies in the ingredients used, the quality of the material, the reputation of the brand, and the price. These few things are what sets these two apart.
What’s the Difference Between A Mr. Clean Magic Eraser and Melamine Sponge?
There are a few differences between a Mr. Clean Magic Eraser and a Melamine Sponge. The first difference to note is the price point. Any line you choose, Mr. Clean Magic Erasers tend to run more expensive than a simple melamine sponge.
In addition, no-name melamine sponges are often available in bulk, whereas Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is not. Another critical difference is the design of the sponge itself. The design is important because it aids in the feasibility of cleaning and how it can reach tough places. It also helps with overall comfort.
The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser features a comfortable ergonomic design with comfortable placement for fingers to rest while scrubbing. Small bends inwards on the sides of the magic eraser create a place where your fingers will naturally rest. This shape makes it easier to clean hard-to-reach nooks and corners. In contrast, a melamine sponge is a rectangle shape.
Mr. Clean Magic Erasers have undergone a specific heat compression routine designed to increase durability. As a result, melamine sponges tend not to be as durable but still great. Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is available in different forms.
Different magic erasers, ranging from bathrooms and soap scum to kitchen grease and difficult glass stovetops, are available. Mr. Clean has an extensive range of products that have been developed to make cleaning as easy as possible. Mr. Clean’s products are backed by years of happy customers and thousands of happy reviews. A melamine sponge is simply a melamine sponge. It is free of fragrance cleaners, and its material is not as robust as the magic eraser.
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Different Forms:
- Bath – suitable to remove soap scum
- Kitchen – perfect for removing grease
- Bath – foaming sponge
- Magic Eraser Sheets
Melamine sponges are a budget-friendly cleaning tool. They are effective on tough marks and also require only water. Additionally, Melamine sponges don’t have any chemicals and are scent-free. Mr. Clean Magic Eraser has a Bath version that is Lavender scented for optimal freshness.
Melamine sponges can efficiently clean through grease, dirt, grime, and permanent marks you thought were impossible to get off. Both options are identical in being reusable.
Though for how long is different. Mr. Clean Magic Erasers are stronger and more resilient, making them last longer and less wasteful. Magic Eraser claims to have twice the strength of cleaning performance and clean the toughest messes.
Are Magic Erasers Just Melamine Foam?
The original Mr. Clean magic eraser is melamine foam. However, other Mr. Clean magic eraser products have additional ingredients.
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Bath with Febreze Lavender Scent
- Melamine Resin Foam
- PEG/PPG Propylheptyl Ether
- Polyoxyalkylene Substuted Chromophore Red and Blue
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Bath with Gain Original Scent
- Melamine Resin Foam
- PEG/PPG Propyheptyl Ether
- Polyoxayalkylene Substituted Chromophore Yellow and Blue
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Kitchen with Dawn
- Melamine Resin Foam
- PEG/PPG Propylheptyl Ether
- Polyoxyalkylene Substuted Chromophore Blue
What Mr. Clean Magic Erasers Are Available?
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Extra Durable Pro
The extra durable magic eraser is a strong cleaning tool. It is 4x stronger with Durafoam and perfect for difficult surfaces like barbeque grills and oven doors. This particular magic eraser is free of harsh chemicals and only requires water. It is perfect for most household surfaces and can be reused several times.
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Original
The Original Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is made with 2x stronger Durafoam. It is tough on dirt and challenging stains. This magic eraser cleans with only water and doesn’t have any harsh chemicals.
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Kitchen
The kitchen Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is a powerful cleaning tool. It is tough on grease and perfect for glass stovetops, granite countertops, and appliances. The Mr. Clean Kitchen Magic Eraser only uses water to clean.
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Bathroom
The Bathroom Mr. Clean Magic Eraser has a fresh, lavender scent. It erases 3x more soap scum than the leading all-purpose spray cleaner. In addition, the bathroom magic eraser is tough on hard-to-clean bathroom spots like the sink, plugs, and bathtub.
Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Sheets
The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser sheets are ideal for knobs, taps, and other hard-to-read places. The sheets are thin and require only water to activate the cleaning process.
Are Magic Erasers More Expensive than Melamine Sponges?
Yes, Mr. Clean Magic Erasers are more expensive than melamine sponges, but many more options are available.
How Many Times Can You Use A Mr. Clean Magic Eraser?
How many times you can use a Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is dependent mainly on the intensity of the scrubbing and how big of a job it is being used. For smaller jobs, a Mr. Clean Magic Eraser could last several times. These smaller jobs involve lighter scrubbing and are more gentle on the magic eraser. Larger jobs that require more vigorous scrubbing are harder on the magic eraser. You can imagine approximately 1-2 big jobs from a Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. Mr. Clean Magic Erasers used for lighter jobs will typically last a few weeks.
Do No Name Melamine Sponges Last Just As Long?
It’s largely dependent on the intensity of the job when considering how long a no-name melamine sponge will last. Mr. Clean Magic Erasers’ are made with strong Durafoam and are slightly more durable than no-name Melamine sponges. However, the length of time that a magic eraser lasts, be it Mr. Clean or a no-name Melamine sponge, is primarily dependent on the intensity of the cleaning.
The Verdict – What Should I Buy?
The melamine sponge and the Mr. Clean magic eraser products demonstrate excellent cleaning results. The melamine sponge is scent-free and available in bulk. Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is available in different strengths and manufactured for specific rooms. For heavy-duty kitchen messes, Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Kitchen will help you clean it quickly while the Bathroom edition cuts down soap scum easily and quickly. Certain Mr. Clean magic eraser products have a light scent, whereas melamine sponges are entirely scent-free. If you require a large amount, the bulk melamine sponge option can be good.
The Mr. Clean Magic Erasers are comfortable and have a great design to rest your fingers. The unique design allows for easier access to tricky places as well. If you’re on a budget, a melamine sponge is great. They are budget-friendly and just as effective as most magic erasers.
Jamie is the Founder of My Home Dwelling. He is a homeowner and enjoys sharing his homeowner tips with others. He has real estate experience working as a new home construction Realtor. Jamie has worked on numerous residential construction sites helping with interior and exterior renovations. He loves refinishing furniture, DIY home projects, and sharing his knowledge online.