Easy-Off vs Goo Gone | What’s the Better Oven Cleaner?

Ovens get dirty so quickly! Grease, oil, baked-on food, and general daily use always creates a lot of tough build-up. Easy-Off and Goo Gone are two powerful cleaners designed to cut through thick layers of tough messes and leave your oven sparkling clean. So, which is better?

To determine whether Easy-Off or Goo Gone is the better oven cleaner, we’re going to do an in-depth review on both products. We’ll also take a look at their ingredients, affordability, and the types of surfaces each can clean.

If you’re looking for a powerful oven cleaner and can’t decide between Easy-Off and Goo Gone, then you’re in the right place! Let’s dive right into comparing these two products so you can see which is the better oven cleaner.

What’s The Difference Between Easy-Off and Goo Gone Oven Cleaner?

The difference between Easy-Off and Goo Gone lies in their ingredients. Goo Gone, as a company, is focused on sustainability and lowering their environmental impact. Their oven cleaner is biodegradable, uses fewer harsh chemicals, and is less toxic than Easy-Off.

We’ll explore this later in this guide, but first let’s dive into reviewing each brand’s oven cleaners!


Easy-Off was invented in 1932 by Herbert McCool. He created the world’s specific oven cleaner and began selling his product door-to-door during the Great Depression. In 1946, Herbert McCool passed away, and his widow took up the mantle of selling Easy-Off.

She started selling the product in Canada and eventually sold the rights to their product to American Home Products. Easy-Off is now produced by Reckitt Benckiser. It’s become one of the most popular oven cleaners available on the market. We’re going to review their product now to find out why.

Easy-Off Oven Cleaners

Easy-Off has two oven cleaning products. They’re both powerful cleaners that will effectively cut through the mess in your oven, but they are slightly different. Let’s dive right in!

Easy-Off Heavy Duty Oven Cleaner Easy-Off Heavy Duty Oven Cleaner, Regular Scent 14.5 oz Can

Easy-Off’s original oven cleaner is specially formulated to penetrate deep, baked-on, tough messes in as little as 3 minutes. You can use this for an occasional deep clean or a daily spot cleaner for tough messes. This product is easy to use, and can be used on your oven, stovetop, broiler, and more!

Easy-Off Oven Cleaner Fume Free Easy Off Heavy Duty Oven and Grill Cleaner Multi, 14.5 Ounce (Pack of 1)

The second oven cleaner Easy-Off has available is still effective at eliminating tough, baked-on messes, grease, and oils, but it’s also fume free! You can use this oven cleaner on all the same surfaces as their original product, and it’s safe to use with self-cleaning ovens.

Easy-Off Fume Free Oven Cleaner Spray, Lemon, 24oz, Removes Grease

The great thing about Easy-Off’s oven cleaners is that both products come in an advanced version. The Easy-Off Pro Oven Cleaners are formulated to be extra powerful cleaners suitable for commercial use.

How to Use Easy-Off Oven Cleaner?

You can follow the same instructions for all of Easy-Off’s oven cleaners, with a few exceptions. For their original formula and it’s pro version, you must make sure to always wear long gloves when handling this product.

Now, regardless of which version you’re using, you can follow these simple steps to use them while cleaning your oven.

For Spot Cleaning

  • Spray in your cold oven from a distance of 9-12 inches
  • Allow product to sit for 30 seconds
  • Wipe the area clean with a damp sponge, cloth, or paper towel

For Deep Cleaning

  • Preheat your oven to 200 degrees F, then turn it off
  • Spray product from a distance of 9-12 inches
  • Allow the product to sit for 1 hour and 15 minutes
  • Wipe the area clean with a damp sponge, cloth, or paper towel

It’s also important to remember to hold the spray bottle pointed away from yourself at all times.

What Are The Ingredients in Easy-Off?

The ingredients in Easy-Off are prominently listed on their website, which shows this company’s dedication to full exposure so their customers understand and feel comfortable with the products they’re using.

Here are the ingredients found in Easy-Off’s original oven cleaner.

  • Water
  • Butane
  • Sodium Hydroxide
  • Dipropylene Glycol Propyl Ether
  • Ethanolamine
  • Benzyl Alcohol
  • Smectite Clay
  • Parrafin Wax
  • Fragrance

Most of these ingredients are powerful cleaners and have a high level of flammability. Be careful to never store this product near an open flame, or in temperatures exceeding 120 degrees F.

Is Easy-Off Toxic?

Easy-Off is a toxic cleaner. It contains several harsh, toxic chemicals, including dipropylene glycol propyl ether, butane, and ethanolamine. Many of these chemicals can cause serious irritation to your skin, and could even burn you. This is why it’s so important to use the proper gloves while cleaning with this product.

Goo Gone

Goo Gone was invented in 1984 by Magic America. Originally, this company focused on products that eliminated residue left behind by adhesives. However, after their original product became successful, they began branching out and creating a whole line of household cleaning products.

This company has a strong focus on sustainability. They try their best to create eco-friendly products that are biodegradable, and safe for you, your pets, and the environment.

Goo Gone Oven Cleaner

Goo Gone only has one oven cleaner, but their powerful formula makes it a standout product. Let’s get right into reviewing their oven cleaner!

Goo Gone Oven & Grill Cleaner Goo Gone Oven and Grill Cleaner - 28 Ounce - Removes Tough Baked On Grease and Food Spills Surface Safe

This Oven & Grill cleaner is biodegradable, VOC compliant, and free of fumes. This powerful cleaner uses foaming technology that clings to a surface and eats away at tough, caked-on messes. While it’s made for use on your oven or grill, metal and hard plastic surfaces are also safe to clean with this product. You shouldn’t use this product on aluminum or faux stainless steel surfaces, as it can damage those materials.

How to Use Goo Gone Oven & Grill Cleaner?

Before you use Goo Gone’s Oven & Grill cleaner, make sure that your oven is turned off and cool to the touch. You don’t need to wear gloves with this product, but someone with sensitive skin should, just in case.

Once your oven is cool to the touch, you can follow these simple steps it get it clean:

1. Spray the area that needs cleaning from a distance of 8-10 inches

2. Close oven door or grill top and allow the product to sit for 3-5 minutes. For deep cleaning, allow the product to sit for 30-60 minutes.

3. Easily wipe clean with a damp sponge, cloth, or paper towel

4. Rinse the nozzle of the Goo Gone Cleaner to remove any residual product. Rinse the surface that was just cleaned thoroughly with water and dry with a cloth or paper towel if it’s a food contact surface.

And that’s it! Goo Gone is an effective cleaner that works more quickly than most oven cleaners.

What Are The Ingredients In Goo Gone Oven Cleaner?

Despite Goo Gone’s products being biodegradable and VOC compliant, it’s still a powerful cleaner with equally powerful ingredients. Here are the ingredients found in Goo Gone’s oven cleaner.

  • Water
  • Diethylene Glycol Monobutyl Ether
  • Sodium Hydroxide
  • Sodium Lauryl Sulfate
  • Triisopropanlamine
  • Alkyl Glucoside
  • Tetrasodium EDTA
  • Betaine
  • Xanthan Gum
  • 2-Butoxyethanol

Some of these ingredients are harsh chemicals that can cause skin irritation and other issues, but we’ve delve further into this subject in the next section.

Is Goo Gone Toxic?

You might be inclined to think that Goo Gone is non-toxic given the fact that it’s biodegradable and VOC compliant, however this product does contain some levels of toxicity.

According to their Safety Data Sheet, Goo Gone’s Oven & Grill Cleaner is labeled as a potential hazard for skin irritation/corrosion, as well as eye irritation/damage. That’s why you should only use this product as directed, and seek medical attention if you accidentally get some in your eyes, nose, or mouth.

Comparison Questions (Easy-Off vs. Goo Gone Oven Cleaner)

Is Easy-Off or Goo Gone More Affordable?

One of the biggest deciding factors that people keep in mind when choosing between two products is their affordability. Finances can be tight and finding the product that hurts your wallet the least is essential!

Since Easy-Off and Goo Gone sell their products in different sizes, the best way to determine which is the more affordable product is to break down their price points to the cost per ounce. Here’s a table that illustrates that breakdown:

Brand Price Per Ounce
Easy-Off $0.31
Goo Gone $0.50

As you can see, Goo Gone is nearly twice the price of Easy-Off! That price difference can really add up over time and definitely sets Easy-Off as the more affordable cleaner.

Which Product is More Powerful?

Easy-Off and Goo Gone’s oven cleaners are both meant to eliminate the same types of messes, and work on the same types of surfaces. So, how do we determine which is more powerful?

First is to look at their ingredients. Easy-Off has more powerful cleaning agents and surfactants in their ingredients, which gives it an edge over Goo Gone. When you look at customer reviews of both products, you’ll see that Easy-Off has an average rating of 4.6/5 stars, while Goo Gone has an average rating of 4.3/5 stars.

Based on their ingredients and levels of customer satisfaction, it seems that Easy-Off is the more powerful and effective cleaner.

Which Product is More Environmentally Friendly? Goo Gone Adhesive Remover - 8 Ounce - Surface Safe Adhesive Remover Safely Removes Stickers Labels Decals Residue Tape Chewing Gum Grease Tar

The clear winner here is Goo Gone. Their products are biodegradable, and are listed as not being an environmental or marine hazard in their SDS (with the exception of unexpected and unprofessional handling and disposal).

Easy-Off isn’t biodegradable and is an environmental hazard. So, if you’re looking for the most eco-friendly oven cleaner between these two, you should definitely go with Goo Gone.

Related Questions

How Do You Get Rid Of Easy-Off Residue?

Sometimes Easy-Off can leave behind a chemical odor and residue. The best way to remove this residue is by mixing a 50/50 solution of water and vinegar. Wipe down the surface you cleaned with Easy-Off thoroughly to remove any traces of the residue. Then, allow your oven to heat up so it can evaporate any remaining traces.

Can You Use Goo Gone Oven Cleaner On Self-Cleaning Ovens?

You can use Goo Gone Oven Cleaner on self-cleaning ovens. It’s surface safe, which means it won’t damage, scratch, or otherwise harm your oven.

Can You Use Goo Gone Oven Cleaner On Oven Glass?

It’s perfectly safe to use Goo Gone Oven Cleaner on your oven’s glass. This product is safe to use on all sealed surfaces including your oven’s glass, sealed stone, ceramics, and metals.

The Verdict – Which Is Better?

Easy-Off and Goo Gone are both similar products in that they serve the same purpose. However, Goo Gone’s formula is less toxic and safer for the environment than Easy-Off’s. It will still effectively clean your oven without harming you or the environment in the process.