Arm and Hammer vs All Detergent

Arm & Hammer vs All Detergent | What’s Better?

In Cleaning Products, Laundry by Jamie

Arm and Hammer and All Detergent are both well-known brands in the laundry detergent world. Determining which brand is better can be challenging, which is why we’ve researched both brands extensively to give you the inside scoop.

When comparing Arm and Hammer vs All Detergent, it’s clear that Arm and Hammer is the better detergent. This brand offers more options, has more effective products, and is more environmentally friendly.

Do you want to know more about why blank is the better laundry detergent? Let’s dive right into the details about both brands, their products, and how they compare so you can see for yourself why blank is the better laundry detergent.

What’s the Difference Between Arm and Hammer and All Detergent?

The difference between Arm and Hammer and All Detergent lies in their products. All detergent has a solid range of options for their customers to choose from, but Arm and Hammer has multiple lines of detergent and other laundry-related products that can take care of everyone’s laundry needs. We’ll dive deeper into the products offered by each brand further in this guide.

Arm and Hammer

Arm and Hammer is an iconic and trusted brand that’s been around for decades. They provide household products for nearly everything, ranging from cat litter to household cleaners and laundry detergent.

This brand is very environmentally focused and matches 100% of the energy used to create their products with renewable energy source credits. While they’ve grown into a global brand, they also maintain their roots as a trusted household brand.

The classic Arm and Hammer logo was created in 1867, and the company has come a long way since then. They introduced their first laundry detergent product in 1970, and it was the first phosphate-free detergent.

Since then, the company has continued to expand its markets and products while maintaining their dedication to protecting the environment.

What Products Does Arm and Hammer Offer?

Arm and Hammer offers a massive variety of products, and their laundry products see a wide selection as well. Let’s start dive right in to the laundry detergents that Arm and Hammer has available.

Liquid Detergents:

Arm & Hammer Liquid Laundry Detergent Arm & Hammer Liquid Laundry Detergent, Clean Burst Dual HE, 144.5oz 107 Loads

Arm and Hammer’s original laundry detergent formula is tough on stains and odors. This concentrated formula uses less water than previous versions, so you know you’re getting the most cleaning possible with each cap full. You can get their original laundry detergent in a clean burst and tropical paradise fragrance. This detergent has a low suds formula, so it’s safe to use with all machines.

Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean Odor Blasters Fresh Burst, 70 Loads Laundry Detergent, 122.5 Fl oz

These products combine the powerful cleaning formulas of OxiClean and Arm & Hammer to create a product that eliminates odors, stains, and other unwanted residues from your laundry. These detergents are formulated to blast away any odors, and you can get them in the following fragrances; fresh scent, fresh burst, and clean meadow. You can also get this in a super concentrated formula, powder formula, or laundry pak.

Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Free & Clear Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Free & Clear, 107 Loads Liquid Laundry Detergent, 144.5 Fl oz

This detergent is perfect for people who are sensitive to dyes, chemicals, or fragrances. It’s hypoallergenic and dermatologist tested to be safe for people with sensitive skin. Free & Clear detergent will still provide your laundry with a powerful and effective clean while also being gentle on your skin.

Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Plus Fresh Scent Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Plus Fresh Scent, 100 Loads Liquid Laundry Detergent, 150 Fl oz

This detergent provides all the benefits of their Free & Clear product, with the added benefit of a fresh scent. Baking soda is included in Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Plus Fresh Scent, which gives it a sensitive skin friendly fresh scent.

Arm & Hammer Baby Liquid Detergent ARM & HAMMER Baby, 75 Loads Liquid Laundry Detergent, 118.1 Fl oz

When you bring your newborn home, you’re going to need a detergent that’s powerful enough to get all their little onesies clean but gentle on their skin. Arm & Hammer baby is a hypoallergenic formula free of phosphates, dyes, and preservatives. It will clean and freshen your baby’s clothes and be gentle on their skin.

Arm & Hammer Clean & Simple Arm & Hammer Clean & Simple, 75 Loads Liquid Laundry Detergent, 118.1 Fl oz

Arm & Hammer Clean & Simple delivers a powerful clean to your laundry with only 6 essential ingredients. This detergent contains water, an active stain remover, Arm & Hammer Baking soda, a laundry booster, a water softener, and a gentle fragrance. This is a great product for those who truly want to feel secure knowing every ingredient that’s in their detergent.

Arm & Hammer Laundry Detergent Plus Softener 

If you want all the cleaning and freshening power of Arm & Hammer Detergent with added softener, then this is the perfect product for you! Arm & Hammer Plus Softener cleans, softens, and freshens your clothes all with one convenient product.

Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean Super Concentrated Arm & Hammer Plus Oxiclean Super Concentrated 60 Loads Liquid Laundry Detergent, Fresh, 15.27 Fl Oz (Pack of 2)

Arm & Hammer super concentrated detergent has 3x the cleaning power per drop as their original formula. It’s easy to pretreat clothes with this lightweight bottle and pump. A single 15.27 fluid ounce bottle can last you up to 30 loads!

Powder Detergents:

Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean Powder Laundry Detergent Arm & Hammer Plus OxiClean Powder Laundry Detergent, Fresh Scent, 45 Loads

This product combines the stain-fighting power of OxiClean with Arm & Hammer’s unique laundry detergent formula. This powdered detergent comes in a fresh scent or tropic burst fragrance.

Arm & Hammer Powder Laundry Detergent Arm & Hammer 33200-00109 Powder Laundry Detergent, Clean Burst, 9.86 lb. (Pack of 3)

This product contains their original laundry detergent formula, but in a powdered form. You can get their powdered detergent in a clean burst or alpine clean fragrance.

Other Laundry Products:

Arm & Hammer 4-in-1 Laundry Detergent Power Paks Arm & Hammer 4-in-1 Laundry Detergent Power Paks, Fresh, 58 Count (Pack of 4)

Forget measuring and messes in the laundry room with these Arm & Hammer Power Paks. All you need to do is drop one pak into your washer and let it get to work! You get all the benefits of Arm & Hammer’s detergent with none of the mess. You can get a pak in all of their PlusOxi fragrances as well as original scent, clean burst and sensitive scent.

Arm & Hammer In-Wash Scent Booster Arm & Hammer in-Wash Scent Booster, Purifying Waters, 37.8 oz

Arm & Hammer has a handful of scent boosters available to help keep your laundry smelling fresh for longer. Under their sensations scent boosters line they have 5 fragrances, including fresh burst, maui sunset, purifying waters, tropical paradise, and meadow scent. Under their clean & simple scent boosters line you can choose between crisp clean or lavender escape fragrances.

Arm & Hammer Dryer Sheets Arm & Hammer - CDC 14995 3320000102 Essentials Dryer Sheets, Mountain Rain, Box of 144 Sheets (Case of 6 Boxes)

Arm & Hammer has a few lines of dryer sheets available that will help keep your clothes fresh, reduce wrinkling, and reduce static. You can choose from all the fragrances available in their clean sensations line. They also have an Essentials line with lavender and linen and mountain rain scents available. Arm & Hammer also has a Free & Clear dryer sheets available that are safe for people with sensitive skin.

Arm & Hammer Super Washing Detergent Booster Arm & Hammer Super Washing Soda Detergent Booster & Household Cleaner, 55oz.

This detergent booster can be added along with your detergent to help fight tough stains, soften fabrics, and eliminate odors. It can also be used as a household cleaner.

How to Use Arm & Hammer Laundry Detergent?

Arm & Hammer laundry detergent is super easy to use. All you do is measure out the amount of liquid you need and add it to your washer’s detergent dispenser or drum. Their laundry paks make it even easier as you just add a single pack into the washer’s drum and let it get to work.

What Are The Ingredients in Arm & Hammer Laundry Detergent?

The ingredients in Arm & Hammer’s laundry detergents can vary widely depending on which product and line you’re looking at. Here are the ingredients in their original clean burst laundry detergent:

  • Water
  • Sodium sulfate
  • C12-15 alcohols ethoxylated
  • Sodium carbonate
  • Sodium C10-16 alkylbenzenesulfonate
  • Disodium distyrylbiphenyl disulfonate
  • Tetrasodium EDTA
  • Acrylic acid homopolymer
  • Sodium hydroxide
  • Sodium bicarbonate
  • Colorant
  • Fragrances

Arm & Hammer Baby vs Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin

Arm & Hammer baby is designed specifically with newborns in mind. That formula is created to be tough on messes and odors while being extremely gentle on your baby’s skin. Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin has similar ingredients, but the composition is slightly different. This product is formulated to be safe for people with sensitive skin, but doesn’t take it to the same level as their baby detergent.

Is Arm & Hammer Toxic?

Arm and hammer isn’t exactly toxic, but it contains ingredients that can be harmful to your health. Arm & Hammer detergents should never be used other than as directed. If the detergent ever comes into contact with your eyes, nose, or mouth, or if you have a reaction when it touches your skin, you should contact your poison control center immediately.


All Detergent

All detergent came onto the market in 1959. This company dedicated itself to providing customers with laundry detergent that is efficient, fresh, and cleans well. This brand had marketed itself as a family-friendly detergent, and that they’re the perfect choice for parents.

Their detergents are advertised as being tough on stains and common messes like mud, dirt, oil, etc. They came out with a few different lines of products dedicated to meeting a wide variety of customer’s needs, and we’re going to get into the details of those products in this guide.

What Products Does all Detergent Offer?

All Laundry Detergentall Laundry Detergent Liquid, Fights Tough Stains, High Efficiency Compatible, 2X Concentrated, 110 Loads

The original all laundry detergent is part of their Stainlifter line. All the detergents in this line clean with a 4-in-1 action that lifts stains, whitens, brightens, and leaves your clothes with a fresh scent. The other detergents in this line include:

All Baby Liquid Laundry DetergentAll Baby Liquid Laundry Detergent, Gentle for Baby, 141 Oz, 94 Loads

This hypoallergenic, dye-free laundry detergent is perfect for washing your baby’s clothes, bedding, and toys. It’s lightly scented and powerful formula will eliminate tough odors and messes, while still being gentle on your baby’s skin.

All Liquid Laundry Detergent Free & Clear all Liquid Laundry Detergent, Clear for Sensitive Skin, 2X Concentrated, 110 Loads

All has a few detergents that are designed specifically for sensitive skin. Their free & clear products are unscented and dye-free. All Free & Clear detergent will remove 99% of common irritants and allergens from your laundry so you can stay comfortable in your clothes.

The other variations on all Free & Clear detergents are:

All Powder Laundry Detergent

All powder laundry detergent has all the power of their original stainlifting formula. It will clean, whiten, brighten, and freshen up your laundry without the potential mess of a liquid detergent.

All Mightly Pacs with Stainlifters All Mighty Pacs with stainlifters free clear Laundry Detergent, Free Clear for Sensitive Skin, 66 Count - (Pack of 2)

These mightypacs come in the same variety of formulas as the rest of all’s detergents. You can get them in free & clear or any of the stainlifters varieties. They work the same as any other laundry pod which means convenience and zero chance of a mess in your laundry room!

How to Use all Detergent?

Using all detergents is a simple and easy process. You simply load your washer, measure out the amount of detergent needed, and add it to your machine’s dispenser or drum. Their detergents are safe for all washers, including front-loading and high-effeciency models.

What Are The Ingredients in all Detergent?

The ingredients in all’s detergents will vary based on which product you’re looking at. Here are the ingredients in their original stainlifter detergent:

  • Water
  • Sodium Lauryl Sulfate
  • Sodium, Citrate
  • Alcohol Ethoxylate
  • Sodium Cocoate
  • Sodium Methylglycine Diacetate
  • Sodium Polyacrylate
  • Protease
  • Calcium Chloride
  • Benzoisothiazolinone
  • Amylase
  • Methylisothiazolinone
  • Manganese
  • Chloromethylisothiazolinone

All Free & Clear vs All Clean & Care

All Clean & Care detergent technically falls under the Free & Clear line, which means that it has all the benefits of all free & clear detergents. It also has some additional benefits. This detergent smooths fibers to promote their ability to stretch and hold their shape. It protects your clothes against the usual wear and tear.

Is all Detergent Toxic?

This detergent isn’t listed as toxic, but they do contain some ingredients that can be harsh to some people. You should only use this detergent as directed, and contact a poison control center immediately if any detergent comes into contact with your eyes, mouth, nose, or if you experience a reaction to it.

Comparison Questions (Arm and Hammer vs All Detergent):

Is Arm and Hammer or All Detergent More Affordable?

One of the biggest factors when debating between Arm and Hammer vs All Detergent is which is the more affordable detergent. Arm and Hammer is more affordable than All Detergent. If you break down the pricing per fluid ounce, you’ll see that you’re paying roughly $0.17 per fl. oz for Arm and Hammer products, and $0.32 per fl. oz for All detergent products.

Which Detergent is More Powerful?

Arm and Hammer’s detergents are more powerful than All Detergents. Their formulas often include Arm and Hammer baking soda or Oxiclean which gives their detergents a big boost over their competitors.

Which Provides a Larger Variety of Products?

Arm and Hammer offers a larger variety of products. While All detergents do have a a few different lines and a wide range of products, they’re no match for Arm and Hammer’s diversity.

Which Product is More Environmentally Friendly?

While both brands have made strides to become more environmentally friendly, Arm and Hammer is the clear winner in this instance. Their brand is Green-e certified, which means that their products and manufacturing processes meet the highest possible standards in North America.

The Verdict – Which Is Better?

Arm and Hammer is the better detergent in this comparison. All detergent has a good range of products, but Arm and Hammer offers more, is more environmentally friendly, and more affordable. Their products also contain baking soda or Oxiclean, which makes them a more effective detergent. If you need a cost-effective detergent brand with a wide range of detergents to choose from, then you should go with Arm and Hammer.

Read our related detergent articles: 

About the Author

Jamie

Jamie is the Founder of My Home Dwelling. He is a homeowner and enjoys sharing his homeowner tips with others. He has real estate experience working as a new home construction Realtor. Jamie has worked on numerous residential construction sites helping with interior and exterior renovations. He loves refinishing furniture, DIY home projects, and sharing his knowledge online.